Using group roles for more effective group work

Post image for Using group roles for more effective group work

by bledsoe on February 2, 2017

Ms. C is a first year lateral entry teacher that I had been working with for a few months, and I was scheduled to visit her second period Marketing class and give her some feedback. It was one of the first few days of the semester and she had divided her students into small groups to do the Marshmallow Challenge, an activity in which teams have eighteen minutes to build the tallest structure they can using only raw spaghetti, string, tape, and a marshmallow. I was familiar with the activity as I'd seen different variations in other teachers' classes. It's a fun and engaging way to have your students get to know each other and also get them used to working in collaborative groups.

Ms. C put the students in groups, explained the rules, gave each group their supplies, and started the timer. Some of the groups had students who began building immediately; some groups had students who sat around for a while staring at each other, trying to figure out where to begin; and some groups seemed to have a combination of both kinds of students, with one or two students who seemed to take over while the others sat and watched.

One of the things I do as an instructional coach is to visit teachers' classrooms and share feedback with them, ideally feedback that will help them to improve their instructional practices. Sometimes a teacher will have very specific things that he or she wants feedback on (e.g., "What kinds of conversations are the students having in their groups?" or "What kinds of questions am I asking during the class discussion?") but often they will just leave it up to me to share things that I think will be useful for them.

As I watched the groups in Ms. C's class I began to wonder about the students who weren't participating. Ideally, every student would be actively participating in the activity, yet that did not appear to be happening. And what exactly did it mean for a student to be "actively participating"? I decided I'd come up with a definition of what "actively participating" meant for this activity, and create a chart that showed Ms. C the students who were and were not active in each group. Later we could decide what the data meant, and if there were things that could be done to increase the active participation rate.

I decided that in order to be considered active, a student had to be doing something more than just watching. Putting together some part of the tower obviously counted, but so did offering suggestions to a teammate; sitting silently didn't count.

Then I created a chart, along with some explanatory comments for Ms. C. Each circle/oval represented a group, and the numbers inside represented the active students while the numbers outside represented the inactive students. ("M" stood for "Male" and "F" stood for "Female.")

When I met with Ms. C after her class to debrief, we talked about ways to get the inactive students to participate, and I suggested adding a rule to the activity that said that each student was responsible for a particular one of the supplies (i.e., the spaghetti, the tape, the string, or the marshmallow) and that only that student could physically touch it. The other students could make suggestions about it, but only one student could touch it. I noted that this was essentially just assigning group roles to the students, something that is generally an effective way to encourage more group participation. She decided to try that for her next class, which was also going to do the Spaghetti Challenge. Here's the chart I created for the next class.

According to the numbers I recorded, the first class had 42% of the students not actively participating, while the second class had just 21%, a pretty impressive improvement just from making a simple tweak to the rules. There might also be some other ideas we could come up with from looking at the data sheets I created. What things do you notice?

Photo Credit: Alejandra Velazquez's STEM Blog


Great Classroom Action

January 1, 2017
Thumbnail image for Great Classroom Action

Another teacher and I were recently trying to come up with a list of the top five best teaching strategies or activities that we had ever seen. I remember thinking, "Man, it's really tough trying to narrow it down to just five," and then I remember thinking, "Hey, this reminds me of Dan Meyer's Great Classroom Action posts." I'm […]

Read the full article →

A Facebook debate on why black lives matter

September 27, 2016

This past summer a conversation almost didn't take place. The two main reasons why it almost didn't take place were 1) it was on Facebook, and 2) it was going to be about police officers shooting and killing black people. I'm not generally a fan of talking about politics on Facebook. It's not a great […]

Read the full article →

Why math is social

July 11, 2016
Thumbnail image for Why math is social

Wilt Chamberlain just taught me how to be a better teacher. Malcolm Gladwell's Revisionist History podcast recently featured an episode called The Big Man Can't Shoot. It's about why good ideas are often not adopted, even when it's clear to everyone that they're good ideas. The episode focused on Hall of Fame basketball player Wilt […]

Read the full article →

What do principals expect to see when they visit your classroom?

April 9, 2016
Thumbnail image for What do principals expect to see when they visit your classroom?

A few weeks ago I was talking with a high school foreign language teacher that I work with about visiting one of her classes, and she suggested that I would probably prefer not to visit her 4th block class because it was one of her advanced classes and so she "wouldn't be teaching much" in […]

Read the full article →

Inspector Columbo is my hero

March 21, 2016
Thumbnail image for Inspector Columbo is my hero

Back in the 1970's there was a popular TV show called "Columbo," which starred Peter Falk as a fictional homicide detective. Columbo came across as a kind of lovable doofus, a kindly almost grandfatherly man, but not particularly bright, and certainly not smart enough to catch the criminals he was trying to catch. Every episode followed pretty much the […]

Read the full article →

How to de-escalate a tense classroom situation

October 30, 2015
Thumbnail image for How to de-escalate a tense classroom situation

For any of you who may have been wondering, in the wake of a recent classroom incident in South Carolina, exactly how that incident could have been handled better by the adults involved, let me offer a thought or two. We had a no cell phones policy at the high school where I taught previously, […]

Read the full article →

You’re gonna have to get over yourself

October 19, 2015

One of the best stories I've heard in a long time is from a podcast called Risk, which I started listening to a few months ago. Fair warning, a lot of their stories are pretty raw, including some with graphic sexuality and stories of abuse, but this one is just a great story from a woman […]

Read the full article →

Teaching math is harder than it looks

October 10, 2015
Thumbnail image for Teaching math is harder than it looks

Last week I had the opportunity to visit a 7th grade math class in an alternative school. Lots of school districts have at least one school like this, in which all the students are there because they've had some sort of difficulty at their "regular" school. Often the kids have been suspended for behavioral reasons, […]

Read the full article →

What does good teaching look like?

September 27, 2015
Thumbnail image for What does good teaching look like?

I had just met a history teacher, Mr. D, in the teacher's lounge. He had stopped by the microwave during his planning period and we were engaged in the kind of casual chit-chat that I often engage in with teachers in my role as a new instructional coach at their school. I'll ask about their school, their classes, […]

Read the full article →